Straight-up winners · 2016–2025

Who won the game?

The 2016–2025 regular seasons are retrospective development results, not a clean holdout, against a 70% target. The model called the winner in 1678-951-10 games (63.8%, n=2629). Betting the favorite on those games won 66.7% (n=2629). The model finished below that baseline by 2.9%. High-confidence calls, model win probability at least 65%, were 72.5% (n=1027). The favorite won 72.9% of those same games, and the model agreed with the favorite 97.5% of the time. The point estimate is above 70% because those games are lopsided favorites, not because the model beat the favorite. No individual season from 2016 through 2025 reached 70% for the model. The 10-season overall rate does not clear 70%.

Model, 10 seasons
63.8%

1678-951-10 · n=2629

Betting favorite
66.7%

Same games with a favorite · n=2629

High confidence
72.5%

745-282-5 · model P ≥ 65% · n=1027

A winner call is the side with the higher model win probability. Ties are excluded from the hit rate. The favorite is the side with the higher moneyline implied probability, or the spread favorite when the moneyline is missing. Pick'ems are not a favorite. Tiers are model win probability: lean 50–58%, medium 58–65%, high 65% and up. Those cuts were set before the 2016–2025 results were read.

By season

2026 is the season to date and is not inside the 10-season total.

SeasonRecordModelFavoriteGapn
2016154-100-260.6%63.8%-3.1%254
2017171-85-066.8%71.5%-4.7%256
2018161-93-263.4%66.5%-3.1%254
2019163-92-163.9%64.3%-0.4%255
2020173-82-167.8%67.8%0.0%255
2021169-102-162.4%62.4%0.0%271
2022171-98-263.6%65.8%-2.2%269
2023165-107-060.7%68.0%-7.3%272
2024183-89-067.3%71.7%-4.4%272
2025168-103-162.0%65.3%-3.3%271
202694-55-163.1%67.8%-4.7%149

By confidence

Lean is a 50–58% model win probability, medium 58–65%, high is 65% and up. The favorite column is the favorite’s win rate on the same games.

lean
53.4%

480-419-3 · favorite 60.2% · n=899

medium
64.4%

453-250-2 · favorite 66.0% · n=703

high
72.5%

745-282-5 · favorite 72.9% · n=1027

Raising the probability cutoff shrinks the number of calls.

Min probabilityModelFavoriten
50%63.8%66.7%2629
55%67.2%68.7%2059
60%71.0%71.9%1518
65%72.5%72.9%1027
70%76.4%77.0%640

On 2639 out-of-sample games, the actual margin regressed on the closing spread and the model-minus-line residual gives the residual a coefficient of 0.011 (SE 0.088, p 0.905). A coefficient near zero means the model is not adding a detectable margin signal beyond the close.

Bankroll simulator

Regular season only, 2016 through 2026 to date, after recent form was removed from the margin. Winner calls are the side with the higher model win probability, settled at that side's closing moneyline. High confidence is a model win probability of at least 65%. Spread and total use the published 3% edge picks. Spread prices use the wider 2015 sigma, and weeks 1–4 are not treated as high confidence. Flat $10 is also 2% of the $500 start. Compounding stakes 2% of the balance after the previous bet, rounded to the cent. A flat bet is skipped, and the path stops, when the balance cannot cover $10.

PathEndingP/LROIMax drawdownLowBets
Moneyline winner calls, flat $10
Stopped 2021-11-14: balance $5.67 could not cover the next $10
$5.67-$494.33-3.5%$494.3398.9%$5.671425of 2785
High-confidence winner calls, flat $10
Played every offered bet
$100.15-$399.85-3.7%$500.3194.7%$27.961092
Spread picks, flat $10
Stopped 2023-12-03: balance $3.97 could not cover the next $10
$3.97-$496.03-3.6%$642.4999.4%$3.971358of 1862
Total picks, flat $10
Stopped 2019-11-24: balance $3.92 could not cover the next $10
$3.92-$496.08-6.8%$592.7399.3%$3.92733of 2271
Always the moneyline favorite, flat $10
Stopped 2021-11-14: balance $6.30 could not cover the next $10
$6.30-$493.70-3.5%$587.3398.9%$6.301418of 2772
Moneyline winner calls, 2% of bankroll
Played every offered bet
$39.88-$460.12-4.4%$463.0492.6%$36.962785
High-confidence winner calls, 2% of bankroll
Played every offered bet
$207.05-$292.95-3.7%$349.1966.0%$179.751092
Spread picks, 2% of bankroll
Played every offered bet
$67.91-$432.09-3.8%$614.6392.2%$52.311862
Total picks, 2% of bankroll
Played every offered bet
$21.18-$478.82-6.5%$575.2696.6%$20.132271

Main path: Moneyline winner calls, flat $10

Balance at the end of each season. Flat paths stay put after they can no longer bet $10.

2016$341.96
2017$338.27
2018$218.45
2019$89.50
2020$152.97
2021$5.67
2022$5.67
2023$5.67
2024$5.67
2025$5.67
2026$5.67

Highest ending balance: High-confidence winner calls, 2% of bankroll

Balance at the end of each season. Flat paths stay put after they can no longer bet $10.

2016$491.00
2017$423.00
2018$449.36
2019$453.52
2020$443.09
2021$323.22
2022$296.84
2023$252.52
2024$251.52
2025$188.46
2026$207.05

Secondary: against the number

These 2016–2025 rows are retrospective development results. The forward record is on the paper ledger. Spread picks leave out recent form, use the 2015 sigma scale, and label weeks 1–4 as caution. Break-even at −110 is 52.4%. The pre-registered bar is a 70% hit rate. Break-even at standard -110 odds is 52.4%. No regular-season slice with at least 200 decided bets reached 70%. No thinner slice printed a 70% point estimate either. Spread at the 3% edge threshold is 889-925-48 (49.0% hit, -4.7% ROI, n=1814). Moneyline at the 3% edge threshold is 754-1271-10 (37.2% hit, -8.1% ROI, n=2025). Total at the 3% edge threshold is 1095-1159-13 (48.6% hit, -5.8% ROI, n=2254). High-confidence spread (edge at least 8%) is 274-281-9 (49.4%, n=555). High-confidence moneyline (edge at least 8%) is 340-649-4 (34.4%, n=989). High-confidence total (edge at least 8%) is 681-745-8 (47.8%, n=1426). Spread volume falls from 2232 bets at any positive edge to 742 bets at an 8% edge. Player-prop ROI against closing lines is not in this report: the free data has no historical prop prices.

spread

02358101215

Bars are bet count. Dots are hit rate. Green tick is 52.4%. Gold tick is 70%.

moneyline

02358101215

Bars are bet count. Dots are hit rate. Green tick is 52.4%. Gold tick is 70%.

total

02358101215

Bars are bet count. Dots are hit rate. Green tick is 52.4%. Gold tick is 70%.

Confidence tier

Lean is 3–5 points of edge, medium 5–8, high is 8 or more. High-only is the right-hand column.

MarketTierRecordHit rateROIn95% interval
spreadlean233-254-1547.8%-7.0%48743.4%–52.3%
spreadmedium285-300-2048.7%-5.0%58544.7%–52.8%
spreadhigh274-281-949.4%-4.0%55545.2%–53.5%
moneylinelean167-265-538.7%-11.0%43234.2%–43.3%
moneylinemedium247-357-140.9%-6.2%60437.0%–44.9%
moneylinehigh340-649-434.4%-8.0%98931.5%–37.4%
totallean161-188-146.1%-10.5%34941.0%–51.4%
totalmedium253-226-452.8%2.3%47948.3%–57.3%
totalhigh681-745-847.8%-7.3%142645.2%–50.3%

By season

Regular season, 3% edge. 2026 is the season to date, not a full year.

Seasonspreadmoneylinetotal
202653.8%49-42-5 · 3.5% ROI44.2%46-58-1 · 8.0% ROI50.8%62-60-0 · -3.0% ROI
202542.7%76-102-1 · -17.8% ROI38.4%78-125-1 · -6.3% ROI51.9%123-114-0 · -0.6% ROI
202449.4%86-88-2 · -4.9% ROI38.0%73-119-0 · -15.6% ROI52.1%113-104-3 · -0.5% ROI
202346.2%79-92-10 · -11.1% ROI33.7%65-128-0 · -14.4% ROI44.2%92-116-2 · -15.5% ROI
202248.6%85-90-7 · -5.0% ROI35.2%68-125-2 · -15.0% ROI47.0%103-116-2 · -8.5% ROI
202145.5%85-102-3 · -11.4% ROI33.7%65-128-1 · -9.8% ROI43.3%107-140-2 · -16.0% ROI
202052.5%93-84-0 · 2.4% ROI36.5%69-120-0 · -16.2% ROI53.2%108-95-3 · 4.0% ROI
201952.3%80-73-8 · 2.1% ROI37.7%69-114-1 · -6.8% ROI50.0%105-105-0 · -2.3% ROI
201851.7%92-86-5 · 0.7% ROI38.0%73-119-2 · 3.3% ROI48.7%95-100-1 · -4.5% ROI
201750.9%81-78-4 · -0.0% ROI35.9%69-123-0 · -6.3% ROI42.4%87-118-0 · -16.6% ROI
201648.5%83-88-3 · -4.1% ROI41.4%79-112-2 · -2.8% ROI52.4%100-91-0 · 2.8% ROI

Calibration

Each dot is a bin of predicted probability against how often that side actually won. A calibrated model sits on the diagonal. ECE is the average gap.

spread

ECE 0.063 · n=2718

moneyline

ECE 0.026 · n=2777

total

ECE 0.106 · n=2768

Grading check

Always betting the home spread covered 48.6% of 2718 decided lines.

A fair closing number lands near 50%. Margin MAE 10.15 · total MAE 11.11.

Postseason, same rules

spread: 42-38-0 · 52.5% · n=80

moneyline: 33-57-0 · 36.7% · n=90

total: 47-39-2 · 54.6% · n=86